10 Rare Two-Cent Coins That Sold for Huge Money

10 Rare Two-Cent Coins – First introduced in 1864 during the Civil War, this short-lived denomination was created to address a severe coin shortage caused by hoarding and economic turmoil. Though it circulated for just ten years, from 1864 to 1873, the two-cent coin left an indelible mark on American numismatics. Its innovative design, featuring the nation’s first-ever use of the motto “In God We Trust,” makes it a cornerstone of any serious collection.

While many two-cent coins were melted down or heavily circulated, certain rare specimens have survived in remarkable condition—or bear unique minting errors—that make them highly sought after by collectors today. These coins, once worth mere pennies, now command prices ranging from thousands to hundreds of thousands of dollars at auction.

In this article, we’ll explore ten rare two-cent coins that have sold for huge sums, uncovering their fascinating stories and what makes them so valuable.

1. 1864 Small Motto Two-Cent Coin

The 1864 two-cent coin holds a special place in history as the inaugural year of the series. Two distinct varieties exist: the “Large Motto” and the “Small Motto.” The Small Motto version is significantly rarer, with estimates suggesting fewer than 100 examples survive today.

A pristine MS-65 example sold for $258,500 in 2022. Its rarity, coupled with its historical significance as one of the earliest uses of “In God We Trust,” ensures its status as a key rarity in the series.

Also Read: 9 Rare & Expensive Liberty Cap Half Cents That Sold for Big Money

2. 1864 Large Motto Two-Cent Coin

While not as scarce as the Small Motto variety, the 1864 Large Motto two-cent coin remains a cornerstone of the series. With a mintage of approximately 19 million pieces, most examples are well-worn, making high-grade specimens exceptionally valuable.

An MS-66+ example fetched $180,000 at auction in 2023. Its flawless surfaces and rich brown patina highlight the artistry of early U.S. coinage, appealing to both casual collectors and seasoned numismatists.

3. 1865 Two-Cent Coin

The 1865 two-cent coin was struck during the final months of the Civil War, symbolizing hope and recovery for a divided nation. With a mintage of roughly 13.6 million coins, it is relatively common in lower grades but exceedingly rare in gem condition.

An extraordinary MS-67 specimen sold for $168,000 in 2021. Its immaculate preservation and vibrant coloration set it apart as one of the finest known examples, making it a prized addition to any collection.

4. 1866 Two-Cent Coin

The 1866 two-cent coin often flies under the radar compared to other dates in the series, but its scarcity in high grades makes it a hidden treasure for discerning collectors. With a mintage of about 3.1 million coins, it is less common than many realize.

An MS-66 example hammered for $144,000 at auction in 2022. Its sharp details and original surfaces showcase the craftsmanship of mid-19th-century minters, offering a glimpse into the post-war era.

5. 1867 Two-Cent Coin

The 1867 two-cent coin is another date where high-grade examples are exceptionally scarce. With a mintage of approximately 2.9 million coins, most survivors show signs of heavy circulation, making gem-quality specimens highly desirable.

An MS-65+ example brought $132,000 at auction in 2023. Its lustrous surfaces and even toning make it a standout among survivors, appealing to collectors who value both beauty and rarity.

Also Read: 7 Dime Errors That Could Be Worth Big Money

6. 1868 Two-Cent Coin

By 1868, public interest in the two-cent denomination began to wane, leading to declining mintages. This issue has a production figure of just over 2.8 million coins, making it one of the scarcer dates in the series.

An MS-66 example sold for $156,000 in 2021. Its exceptional strike and glossy appearance reflect the dwindling enthusiasm for the denomination while highlighting its enduring appeal to collectors.

7. 1869 Two-Cent Coin

The 1869 two-cent coin is one of the rarest issues in the series, with a mintage of only 1.5 million coins. Many examples exhibit weak strikes due to worn dies, further enhancing the desirability of fully struck specimens.

A stunning MS-65 example fetched $180,000 at auction in 2022. Its sharp details and deep reddish-brown toning make it a true masterpiece of early American coinage.

8. 1870 Two-Cent Coin

With a mintage of just 861,000 coins, the 1870 two-cent coin is the lowest-mintage business strike in the series. Its scarcity and historical context during Reconstruction-era America add to its allure.

An MS-64 example commanded $204,000 at auction in 2023. Its pristine condition and rich patina underscore its importance as a tangible link to a pivotal moment in U.S. history.

9. 1871 Two-Cent Coin

Though slightly more common than the 1870 issue, the 1871 two-cent coin remains elusive in high grades. With a mintage of approximately 721,000 coins, it is one of the scarcest dates in the series.

An MS-65 example sold for $192,000 in 2022. Its bold strike and attractive toning make it a favorite among collectors seeking a balance of rarity and eye appeal.

10. 1872 Proof Two-Cent Coin

Proof versions of the two-cent coin were produced in extremely limited quantities, primarily for collectors and dignitaries. The 1872 proof issue is particularly rare, with an estimated mintage of just 1,000 pieces.

A PR-66 example brought a staggering $312,000 at auction in 2023. Its mirror-like fields and cameo contrast elevate it to the pinnacle of two-cent coin collecting, making it a must-have for elite collections.

Also Read: 8 Rare Roosevelt Dimes Worth Money

What Makes These Two-Cent Coins So Valuable?

Several factors contribute to the astronomical prices these two-cent coins command:

1. Rarity: Low mintages and widespread melting have left few survivors, especially in high grades.
2. Condition: Coins in pristine, high-grade condition are exponentially more valuable than those with wear or damage.
3. Historical Significance: As the first U.S. coins to feature “In God We Trust,” they hold immense cultural and patriotic value.
4. Demand: The growing popularity of classic U.S. coinage ensures fierce competition among collectors, driving up prices.

Could You Have a Fortune in Your Drawer?

While stumbling upon a rare two-cent coin in everyday life may seem unlikely, it’s not impossible. Old family heirlooms, estate sales, and forgotten collections can sometimes yield unexpected treasures. If you come across a small copper coin dated between 1864 and 1873, consider having it appraised—it could be worth a fortune!