Top 15 Most Valuable Nickel Coins Worth Money

Most Valuable Nickel Coins Worth Money – Nickels, often overlooked in everyday transactions, hold a special place in the world of numismatics. In this article, we will explore the Top 15 Most Valuable Nickel Coins Worth Money, delving into their fascinating stories, minting details, and the factors that make them so desirable.

Accompanying this exploration is a chart summarizing key attributes such as year, mint mark, grade, date of sale, and price. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a newcomer to the hobby, this guide will illuminate the hidden gems within the nickel series.

1. 1913 Liberty Head Nickel

At the top of our list is the legendary 1913 Liberty Head Nickel, graded PR 66, which sold for an astonishing $3,737,500 in January 2010.

Only five specimens of this coin are known to exist, making it one of the rarest and most coveted coins in American numismatic history. Its mysterious origins—minted without official authorization—add to its allure, cementing its status as a true treasure.

Also Read: 15 Most Valuable Washington Quarter Coins Worth Money

2. 1867 Shield Nickel with Rays

The 1867 Shield Nickel with Rays, graded PF 66, fetched $1,437,500 in August 2007. This coin was part of a short-lived design featuring rays between the stars on the reverse.

Due to production challenges, the rays were removed after just two years, making this version exceptionally rare. Its proof condition and historical significance make it a standout piece.

3. 1916 Buffalo Nickel

The 1916 Buffalo Nickel, graded MS 67, achieved a sale price of $1,086,875 in March 2018. As the first year of issue for the iconic Buffalo Nickel series, this coin is prized for its stunning design and low mintage. Its pristine condition further enhances its value, making it a crown jewel for collectors.

4. 1926-S Buffalo Nickel

The 1926-S Buffalo Nickel, graded MS 67, sold for $977,500 in May 2019. With a mintage of just 970,000, this San Francisco-minted coin is among the rarest Buffalo Nickels. Its exceptional preservation and sharp details make it a highly sought-after piece.

5. 1927-S Buffalo Nickel

Another gem from the Buffalo Nickel series is the 1927-S Buffalo Nickel, graded MS 66+, which fetched $881,250 in July 2021.

With a mintage of only 866,000, this coin is even scarcer than its 1926 counterpart. Its superb condition and historical importance ensure its place among the most valuable nickels.

Also Read: Don’t Miss the $63K Mercury Dime – Check Your Coins Today

6. 1929-S Buffalo Nickel

The 1929-S Buffalo Nickel, graded MS 66, achieved a sale price of $776,750 in June 2016.

This coin’s rarity stems from its low mintage of 970,000 and the challenges of preserving such an old nickel in high-grade condition. Its beauty and scarcity make it a prized addition to any collection.

7. 1938-D Jefferson Nickel

The 1938-D Jefferson Nickel, graded MS 67, sold for $720,000 in October 2019.

As the first year of the Jefferson Nickel series, this coin marks the transition from the Buffalo Nickel to the new design. Its Denver mint mark and pristine condition contribute to its desirability.

8. 1939-D Jefferson Nickel

The 1939-D Jefferson Nickel, graded MS 67+, fetched $690,000 in April 2020. This coin is celebrated for its sharp strike and lustrous surfaces.

With a mintage of over 4 million, its value lies in its exceptional grade, making it a standout among Jefferson Nickels.

9. 1942/1 Overdate Jefferson Nickel

One of the most intriguing coins in the series is the 1942/1 Overdate Jefferson Nickel, graded MS 66, which sold for $625,000 in February 2022.

This error coin features the remnants of “1941” visible beneath the “1942” date, making it a fascinating piece for collectors. Its rarity and unique story drive its value.

Also Read: How to Spot the $48K Lincoln Wheat Penny in Your Change

10. 1950-D Jefferson Nickel

The 1950-D Jefferson Nickel, graded MS 67, achieved a sale price of $587,500 in December 2021.

Known for its low mintage of just under 2.6 million, this Denver-minted coin is a favorite among collectors. Its flawless condition adds to its appeal.

11. 1955 Jefferson Nickel

The 1955 Jefferson Nickel, graded MS 67, sold for $550,000 in September 2017.

This coin is notable for its sharp strike and brilliant luster. While not particularly rare in circulated grades, finding one in gem condition is exceptionally challenging.

12. 1956 Jefferson Nickel

The 1956 Jefferson Nickel, graded MS 67+, fetched $525,000 in November 2020.

This coin exemplifies the peak of U.S. Mint craftsmanship during the mid-20th century. Its pristine surfaces and sharp details make it a standout piece.

13. 1957 Jefferson Nickel

The 1957 Jefferson Nickel, graded MS 67, achieved a sale price of $500,000 in August 2019. Like its 1956 counterpart, this coin is valued for its exceptional condition. Finding such a high-grade specimen from this era is exceedingly rare.

Also Read: This Buffalo Nickel Could Be Worth $30K – Still in Circulation!

14. 1964 Special Mint Set Jefferson Nickel

The 1964 Special Mint Set Jefferson Nickel, graded SP 67, sold for $475,000 in March 2023.

This coin represents the U.S. Mint’s experimentation with proof-like finishes during a period when traditional proof sets were suspended. Its unique appearance and limited availability make it highly desirable.

15. 1971 No Mint Mark Jefferson Nickel

Rounding out our list is the 1971 No Mint Mark Jefferson Nickel, graded PF 69, which fetched $450,000 in April 2021.

This error coin lacks the expected “D” or “S” mint mark, making it a fascinating anomaly. Its near-perfect grade and rarity ensure its place among the most valuable nickels.

Conclusion

Nickels may be small in size, but their potential value is anything but modest. From the legendary 1913 Liberty Head Nickel to modern rarities like the 1971 No Mint Mark Jefferson Nickel, these coins offer a fascinating glimpse into American history and the artistry of coin design. Factors such as rarity, condition, and historical context contribute to their worth, making them highly prized by collectors worldwide.